A Typology of Infill Architecture Based on Multi-Criteria Decision-Making: A Case Study of the Historic Urban Fabric of Hamadan

Authors

Keywords:

Infill Architecture, Typology, Cluster Analysis, Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM), Historic Urban Fabric of Hamadan

Abstract

Abstract

Historic urban infill interventions require transparent criteria for describing changes in the built fabric. This study develops an exploratory, multi-criteria typology of physical continuity between replacement buildings and their predecessors in a selected part of historic Hamadan, Iran, and examines its conceptual relationship to established design approaches.

Seventeen purposively selected replacement buildings with available pre-demolition photographs were examined. Twenty-eight literature-derived indicators were screened by 22 experts using the Content Validity Ratio (CVR), retaining 13 indicators. The same expert panel supplied Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) judgments to derive indicator weights. Following a four-person pilot assessment, 42 specialists rated each replacement building against the former building on each retained indicator. Building-level scores were calculated using Simple Additive Weighting (SAW), and weighted 13-indicator profiles were classified using Ward hierarchical clustering. Cluster stability was evaluated by resampling the respondents.

The 17 selected buildings formed four exploratory groups: extensive physical transformation (8 buildings), relative retention of volume with façade alteration (5), relative retention of siting with roof and skyline alteration (3), and one distinctive high-similarity case. The four-group solution was stable under respondent resampling (mean adjusted Rand index approximately 0.93), although silhouette coefficients indicated only modest cluster separation. Semes’s framework offered a useful qualitative interpretive analogy rather than a validated one-to-one classification. The SAW rankings were highly correlated under the reported alternative weighting scheme (Spearman’s rho = 0.966). These findings describe physical similarity to former buildings, not a direct measurement of contextual compatibility, designers’ intentions, or the prevalence of intervention strategies throughout Hamadan. Further neighborhood-level assessment is needed before design-policy recommendations can be generalized.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Publication Timeline

Published

Issue

Section

Research-oriented

How to Cite

ُSaedi K. ., Mohamadianmansoor, S., & Mehrabi, A. (2026). A Typology of Infill Architecture Based on Multi-Criteria Decision-Making: A Case Study of the Historic Urban Fabric of Hamadan. Landscape Architecture and Garden Design Journal. https://lagdj.com/index.php/lagdj/article/view/102